(Almost) every spot to shop secondhand in Indianapolis

The impact of fast fashion on the environment has been a hot (no pun intended) topic in recent years - and for good reason. While you may not be able to single-handedly dismantle the fast fashion industry, you can make an impact of your own by shopping secondhand. In honor of Earth Day, we’re offering up a list of secondhand shops here in Indy. Because finding something cool and reducing the need to buy new is always #trending.

 
A woman casually browses a rack of secondhand clothing.

Here’s (almost) every spot to shop secondhand in Indianapolis…and nearby!:

Sales: These happen at different times and locations throughout the year. (Pro tip: sign up for their newsletters to never miss a sale!)

Indy Kids Sale, Indy

Just Between Friends, Indy

Whale of a Sale, Westfield



Curated: These locations offer found, refinished, and uniquely chosen pieces. 

Flipside, Indy

Flux, Indy

Fly's Nest Vintage, Indy

Hoosier Sister, Carmel

Lux and Ivy, Indy

Notorious Vintage, Indy

Nuova Vita Vintage , Indy

The Corner Bazaar, Indy


Consignment: Whether you’re ready to sell that designer denim collecting dust in the back of your closet, or looking for a deal on a new-to-you wardrobe, consignments shops are the answer. 

Amanda's Exchange, Carmel

Newman & Co., Indy

Simply Chic, Plainfield, Greenwood, Noblesville, & Fishers

Sheer Platinum, Indy

Style Threads, Avon

Toggery , Indy



Thrift & Vintage: There’s something to be said about finding the perfect treasure and these thrift shops are just the places to begin your hunt. (Bonus: some even benefit a good cause).

Broad Ripple Vintage, Indy

Grace Care Center, Noblesville

Good News Ministries, Indy

Mission 27 Resale, Indy

Naptown Thrift, Indy

Noblecause, Noblesville

Skull 518 Thrift Shop, Beech Grove

SoBro Vintage Market Antiques & Curiosities, Indy

The Blue Caboose, Beech Grove

Thrifty Threads, Indy

Zodiac Vintage, Indy

Who says fashion can’t be trendy and eco-friendly?

Bonus: Antiques and home goods! Because why should sustainable shopping stop at your closet?

Audrey's Place, Indy

Consigned by Design, Indy

Midland Arts and Antiques, Indy

ReStore, West Washington, Avon, Fisher, & Greenfield

The Velvet Plum, Noblesville


Whether you call it thrifty, vintage, antique, consignment, or secondhand, it’s all sustainable! Did we miss your favorite? Tell us!


Tiffany Shull

Tiffany is an author, editor, and WFH mom of Remy. Though she's lived across the West and Midwest, she settled down with her family in Indy in 2011. She's passionate about uplifting the diverse voices and experiences of women through their writing. Have pitch ideas? Reach Tiffany at editor@theCityMoms.org.

Previous
Previous

Best puberty books for girls: what to read for parents, tweens, and teens

Next
Next

10 things to stop apologizing for right now